After he read my entry here the other day about Mother's Day, my shrink brother posed the following question to me in an email: "If our mother had welcomed Mother's Day gifts and if you now had a warm and convivial relationship with her, do you think you'd still feel the same way about people wishing you a happy Mother's Day?"
Truth be told, in a word, no.
I don't have bad memories about Mother's Day. By the same token, I don't have good memories, either. It was just a day to get through. We dared not wish her a happy Mother's Day or give her a gift. The holiday just didn't exist.
In all honesty, from the time I left my parents' house at age sixteen until I became pregnant, I didn't really think about my mother all that much. She had become a distant relative for me in my memory, like a little-seen aunt or cousin.
Now that I am a mother, however, I think about her much more. I will try not to do anything bad that my mother did to me. My mother had my entire life pre-programmed from the time I was quite young. I was supposed to be a good student, to get into a good college, and then go to a good law school. Never mind I had utterly zero interest in that and, of course, it never happened.
My mother was always hyper-critical, too (and still is, from what I hear through my brother). She didn't do this in a shrewish way but more with psychological manipulation and subtle bullying -- she is a shrink, too, after all. I am determined not to make those kinds of mistakes with my son (and his possible future siblings).
But there are still things I'd like to share with my mother now. I would have liked to talk to her some during my pregnancy. We're 10,000 miles apart, so it's not like I want to drop in every other day or would keep her on the phone.
I might as well send email to a glacier, however. I send my parents pictures of Joey on occasion, and I hear nothing back from my mother. From my father, I get a "thank you for sharing" and that's it.
So, yes, Mother's Day is not a big fluffy bunny of a memory for me. It's not a horrible memory, a locked in the closet and beaten with a wire hanger memory. But it's a reminder of her, the yawning chasm between us, and the fact that no matter what I've tried, she seems to prefer pretending I do not nor have I ever existed.
I'm just so thankful I have a husband, son, and brother whom I love to pieces and who love me back in countless abundance.