Imagine the following scenario: It is the early 1980s. By chance, Sean sees Katie across the room in a New York city lunch place. It's love at first sight for both. He invites her to dinner at an expensive restaurant, which she accepts, and she sees him drop a lot of cash when they're dining.
Katie is a recent immigrant from Ireland. She left the old country because her dad and brothers were gangster types heavily involved in "the troubles." She realizes pretty quickly that Sean is involved in organized crime. She does not know, however, that his job includes whacking people on occasion for the mob.
After dinner, they go back to her place and have mad, passionate sex. They start dating thereafter and see each other constantly. It is true love. They move in together a few weeks into their relationship.
Without her directly asking but because of her, he decides to leave organized crime and lands a legitimate job as a carpenter's apprentice. Katie is elated about that, and the two start making serious plans about marriage and a family.
Then one day Sean's old organized crime pals pay him a visit. They say they respect his going legit. But they have one last job for him -- a hit. He refuses, insisting he's out of his old life. They tell him he has no choice -- either he does the hit or they'll kill Katie. Sean agrees to do the job.
A few days later while cleaning their apartment, Katie finds the gun Sean obtained to kill the mob's target. She's furious. She confronts him about the obvious -- that he's not truly out of the mob and will kill someone with the gun. He admits this is true.
So it boils down to this: Katie will break up with Sean unless he refuses to do the job. He cannot, but he does not tell her why. Even though both madly loves the other, Katie breaks up with Sean. He leaves and does the hit. End of their story.
This is all a subplot in a very good and long novel I'm currently reading. What made me so agitated about this story was the fact that Sean
does not tell Katie why he has to kill. He doesn't tell her he's doing it to protect her. He's doing it out of love. (The guy he's been ordered to kill, by the way, is another mobster who has murdered people in his own right, so he's no choirboy.)
I understand why Sean doesn't tell her why he must kill -- he wants to spare her the guilt that she might feel. But this is where I disagree. Does he think the guilt will be more powerful than the anguish she'll endure in losing the man she loves? (Yes, I know this is about a fictional character, but many parallels could be found in real relationships.)
When it comes to love, I think you have to be very careful when "sparing" your lover the truth. I think honesty is paramount in almost every situation. The exceptions must be the rarest of the rare, and I don't think this is one of them.
If my husband told me that he had to kill some mobster to prevent our son from being killed, I think I would understand. I don't think I'd be plagued by guilt. I might even offer to be his driver.