I'm sure I wasn't alone in feeling sorry for the people who thought they had won, only to have defeat wrenched from the jaws of victory when they were onstage. I have to think the memory of that will be painful for a long time.
A lot of people initially faulted Warren Beatty for the screwup but, as later media reports confirmed, he was not to blame. The Huffington Post published a helpful explanation for what exactly went wrong and how it happened.
The bottom line is Beatty was given the wrong category envelope because of backstage duplicates for every award.
IMHO, the procedure for distributing envelopes to the presenters, detailed in the linked article, seems unnecessarily cumbersome and it's a wonder more screw-ups haven't happened like this before.
The root of the problem seems to be "function follows form" -- the procedure is unnecessarily complicated because of a desire to have pretty presentation envelopes and presenters entering from both wings of the stage.
Oscar envelopes used to be the plain business variety, but because winners like to frame the card and envelope, they've become more elaborate and, in the case of the other night, more difficult to read. And because presenters enter from both sides of the stage, multiple sets of envelopes are available, which in turn could lead to the mishap that happened this year.
Whoever handed the envelope to Warren Beatty was ultimately to blame because the wrong category is clearly printed on the front. But the award ceremony director and/or producer should've had a fail-safe system by impressing upon the presenters to check that they had been given the right category envelope before proceeding onstage.
Accordingly, perhaps the procedures need to be simplified somewhat so once again "form follows function." Who cares if the envelopes look just like ordinary envelopes? And does it matter if the presenters only enter the stage from one side?
Hopefully the Academy of Motion Picture Arts and Sciences will develop a new and better procedure to make certain this kind of error never happens again.


























